SSD or SSHD for my laptop?

Darren

Moderator
Staff member
I've got an ASUS X550LB NH-52 laptop (specs in my signature), and it's hard drive is pretty much garbage. It's a 750GB 5400RPM drive, I think a Seagate. I use the laptop primarily for use on campus and when I want to use a computer sitting somewhere other than my desk. I do game on it occasionally as well. My issue is that most times when I open it up it is insanely slow for up to several minutes while the hard drive "catches" up. System monitor tells me it'll be working at 99 percent a lot of the time on various things from System processes, to Steam, to Skype, or whatever else. Once it settles down the laptop performs ok, but for popping it open to check something real quick it is annoyingly slow. Even with a clean install of W10 and very minimal programs installed, it bogs down easily.

Spec wise the machine is fine for my needs, but the hard drive in it has gotta go. Now given the reason I want a new HDD, would an SSD or an SSHD be a good idea? Boot time on it as it stands now is still pretty quick and I keep it sleeping most of the time anyway. Would an SSHD be quick enough to alleviate the initial slowness when turning it back on? I know they are usually only 5400RPM drives, so I'm hesitant to go down that route. I don't know a lot about them, but understand the basic concept of a small "SSD" cache. Alternatively I could just bite the bullet and get a 500GB SSD, which is still enough space. Although if I went the SSHD route I'd still want a 1TB. My issue there is of course price, and it almost seems like a waste to buy a 500GB SSD and put it in my secondary laptop and not my desktop that I use 90 percent of the time.

Looking at these two in particular, but am open to suggestions. Not too picky about actual speed of the SSD since anything is going to a huge jump.

http://www.amazon.com/Crucial-BX100...c&ie=UTF8&qid=1440265794&sr=1-12&keywords=ssd

http://www.amazon.com/Seagate-Lapto...c&ie=UTF8&qid=1440265368&sr=1-3&keywords=sshd


Another thought is pulling the 120GB 840 EVO out of my desktop for use in the laptop and putting a 500GB in it, but then I'd be very pressed for space. Would need to keep any games I wanted to play on my external 1TB, but that might cause issues as well. I don't know how far 120GB would take me without having to transfer stuff all the time. My laptop only has a slot for one drive, unless I pulled out the DVD drive or something.

Appreciate any response.
 
Get an SSD. Then you don't have to worry about a platter shattering if you accidentally drop it.
 
Well if I drop it enough to shatter the drive, I'll probably have other issues. I'm more asking if the SSHD would help for initial slowness.
 
I'm more asking if the SSHD would help for initial slowness.

Yes, though it won't be as quick as an actual 100% SSD. You should notice more initial speed though. Best bet is to go full SSD, but you'd have to decide if the insane performance boost is worth the money. (Spoiler alert - it is!) YMMV.

The only traditional platter drive in my desktop is for dedicated backup storage. Everything else is solid state.
 
Eh just stick with a standard ssd. The solid portion of the sshd isn't large enough to give you a consistent performance boost
 
Alright thanks guys, I'll probably just do an SSD when I get around to upgrading it. If I could just get Windows Defender to not run on startup I'd probably be fine as it's now the only thing really hogging the hard drive.
 
Definitely SSD. I had an SSHD in my ThinkPad but ended up getting an SSD because the SSHD felt slow - just like a 5400 RPM disk in fact. I don't like SSHDs because they don't really offer any speed benefit and not to mention the Seagate one I had is now dead after a year of very moderate use.
 
It's actually acting pretty happy now that I've go most startup stuff disabled. I might have to install a different AV just so I can disable Defender and control how much my AV is scanning. Defender is seriously broken on W10 due to lack of any options except "on" and "off".
 
It's actually acting pretty happy now that I've go most startup stuff disabled. I might have to install a different AV just so I can disable Defender and control how much my AV is scanning. Defender is seriously broken on W10 due to lack of any options except "on" and "off".

You have to disable windows defender service as well.
 
The SSD portion of the SSHD will need to be large enough to buffer the use, or it becomes slower. Get yourself at chaep 30GB SSD of ebay, and use intels Smart Response. Much better option.
 
Back
Top