touchscreen vs keyboard on mobile devices

jason87x

New Member
I've never had an iphone or anything of that caliber before, but I tried one out and was impressed by the whole touch interface. However I then realized that the touchscreen interface doesn't always work well for things like typing. You need to type text to communicate (aka texting) which is a big part of small mobile devices. So which in your opinion (or if you have scientific facts to back it up) of these three interfaces would be the best?

1. Touchscreen, similar to the iphone. The keyboard is of course on the screen, and the virtual keys would be pretty small, say for example 12mm x 12mm. I've heard "typing" on one of these things can get tiring because most devices like this use glass for the screen. Also I have fat fingers (not fat myself, just huge hands).

2. A physical keyboard, and a screen laptop fold or slide style like some smartphones. Keys would be 12mm x 12mm, assuming a template of a standard 1234567890 QWERTYUIOP. Increasing key size (14mm keys possible alternative) would make device bulky and most likely not pocketable.

3. Something smaller, say like the size of an ipod nano. Small screen, has four arrow buttons and maybe a couple essentials like Enter, Back, Exit, etc. Navigation on a keyboard to input text would be done with arrow keys. Possible option (well for all of them really) would be to have mini USB keyboard of smaller size itself to attach to it.

4. Other ideas?

If you bash the third option, don't bash it because of a small screen. Mobile devices almost always have small screens and I've noticed that large screens are only really needed for three things: gaming (depends on the game type), movies (sometimes, small screens may sometimes be okay for that too), and looking at large pictures or needing large pictures for certain purposes (aka pr0n).
 
4th option would be getting something like the HTC Desire Z, something with both the touchscreen option or the physical option. Honestly You'd have to go out and try for yourself on one..it's hit or miss depending on the person. I find myself wishing I had physical buttons at times, but i can definitely make do with the touch.
 
Complete touchscreens suck. That's why I never got one before my HTC Aria. It's too hard to text with. I'd go with one that is touchscreen and has a physical keyboard as well.
 
I'm more accurate with the touchscreen keyboard on my HTC Desire for some reason. I hate the feel of small mobile keyboards. And phones coming out with features like Samsung's Swype, physical keyboards on phones will hopefully become a thing of the past.
 
I'm more accurate with the touchscreen keyboard on my HTC Desire for some reason. I hate the feel of small mobile keyboards. And phones coming out with features like Samsung's Swype, physical keyboards on phones will hopefully become a thing of the past.

+1

Though I can see the argument for both sides, I really like the touchscreen on iPhone.
 
The touch screen on the iPod Touch ROCKS! I find physical keyboards on small devices tiring, and they have a habit of losing their markings as they age. Going from a full-sized keyboard cell phone to a iPod, I find it much easier to type with the iPod than that cell phone.
But, of course, it really all boils down to your personal preference, some people may not like dirtying their screens, and others prefer the feel of a physical keyboard.
 
+1

Though I can see the argument for both sides, I really like the touchscreen on iPhone.

Agreed. I've used both and I prefer touch over keyboard, although I can see touch being a problem if you have large enough fingers. Luckily most smartphones allow for landscape text entry, which should make it easier for you.
 
Actually I do really like the ability to change touch keyboards...it seems theres a keyboard out there for everybody. That being said my friend with large hands still has some troubles..then again my phone has a 3.2" screen, smaller than most smartphones.
 
I find touchscreen on my cell a bit of a novelty really and belonging to the fat fingers club it does affect accuracy when texting but mostly it's pretty nice to use. I think it works well with ATM machines etc.
 
I went from a Blackberry Bold to a HTC EVO, the Blackberry being keyboarded and the EVO being a strictly touchscreen. I was skeptical about strictly touchscreens are first but the EVO is just that good I had to get it. For starters it takes some getting used to... about 2-3 days for me. Im not a small guy or have small fingers and I can still text well and accurately without the keyboard. Also I have noiced alot of newer touchscreen only phones have a "talk to type" option (not sure about keyboard phones) and I workd nicely, you jsut ahve to speak clearly.
 
Back
Top