Choosing a $100 2.5" hard drive for a MP3 player

[Derk]

Hi, i'm looking for 2.5" for under a $100 to put in a MP3 player. I went to newegg and found to 60GB drives for just under a $100. I need your advice on choosing one of the two. I am also open to suggestions if you know of a better deal.

Choice #1:
Western Digital 60GB 8MB cache 5400rpm's.
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?Item=N82E16822144378

Choice #2:
TOSHIBA 60GB 16MB cache 5400rpm's.
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?Item=N82E16822149038

I am leaning to the WD because I have never had a WD HD fail on me ever. But i'm also leaning to the Toshiba because of the 16MB cache. They both offer a 3 year warranty.

Thanks!

 

[lowcar100]

I would go for the toshiba. you get better performance and the same warranty, also after 3 years how much will you be using the mp3 player?